Perfectly Imperfect:
A Modern Spin on
Engagement Rings
Let’s be honest—your love story isn’t like anyone else’s, so why should your ring be? Salt and pepper diamonds proudly celebrate the quirks that make your bond unique. With their cosmic blend of black and white inclusions, these diamonds are like tiny galaxies, full of charm and personality. The beauty is in their perfectly imperfect nature, making each one as unique as the love it symbolizes. Who needs cookie-cutter when you can have a one-of-a-kind masterpiece?
Why Everyone’s Crushing
on Salt and Pepper Rings
In a world obsessed with perfection, salt and pepper diamonds are stealing hearts ~ and the spotlight ~ for all the right reasons. Their so-called “imperfections” give them depth, mystery, and irresistible raw beauty. Whether your style is sleek and modern or has a vintage vibe, these stones bring a fresh, rebellious streak ~ just like you!
The Diamonds Forever Promise
At Diamonds Forever, we believe your ring should feel like a piece of your story. Our salt and pepper engagement rings are crafted carefully and designed to let each stone’s unique character shine. Whether you’re after something bold or subtle, our team can’t wait to help you create a ring as unforgettable as your love. Are you ready? Let’s make some magic together!
Click below to schedule
your appointment today!
Why settle for the ordinary when you can sparkle with the extraordinary? Let’s design a ring as exciting and beautiful as you are. Ready to start this dazzling jewelry adventure? We can’t wait to create something unforgettable together!
What Our Happy Clients Say
Our clients are the heart of everything we do, and their love stories inspire our passion for bold, unforgettable designs. Could a salt and pepper engagement ring be the perfect way to celebrate your one-of-a-kind bond? Just ask our amazing clients who’ve fallen in love with these one-of-a-kind beauties. We’re beyond excited to be part of their stories and can’t wait to create something extraordinary for you, too!
In 2024, Brian R selected a pear shape salt and pepper crown solitare engagement ring in 18K yellow gold with a satin finish. “I came into Diamonds Forever recently on a mission. I needed an engagement ring, and I needed it fast! I was planning to propose that weekend in Hawaii, and honestly, I wasn’t sure it was possible. But luckily, Jenny and the whole Diamonds Forever team came through! They had an incredible selection of salt and pepper diamond engagement rings. I found the perfect one! I still can’t believe how smoothly it all went! Jenny even gave me something to make the ring fit in case it was too big for the proposal. After returning from Hawaii, we brought the ring to get it sized properly. The proposal went perfectly, and my fiancée is obsessed with the ring. I can’t thank Jenny and the Diamonds Forever girls enough for making this happen. They went above and beyond seriously, and I left with the perfect ring just in time. If you want salt and pepper engagement rings or a fantastic experience, these ladies are the best!”
In 2023, Bond D designed a solitaire engagement ring with an Asscher rose cut salt and pepper diamond set into 14K white gold: “I’m so happy to share with you all the amazing experience I had at the ring store I found online. After visiting several local stores in San Diego and browsing on the world wide internet, I found that Diamonds Forever has the best selection of engagement rings for any budget and taste. I wanted to surprise her with a ring that would make her say yes without hesitation. The ring store had a very helpful and friendly staff who guided me through the process of choosing the perfect ring. They showed me different styles, shapes, colors, and sizes of diamonds and bands. They also explained to me the meaning of the four Cs: cut, clarity, color, and carat. I learned a lot from them and I felt confident in my decision. I finally picked a ring that was stunning and elegant, just like my fiancé. It had a round brilliant salt and pepper cut diamond with small diamonds on the band. It sparkled like a star in the night sky. It was the ring of her dreams. One of the coolest experiences was they made a 3D image of the ring prior to starting the project. This helped tremendously with making sure it was exactly what she wanted. It was the best day of my life and I owe it all to the ring store. They made my proposal unforgettable and they made my fiancé the happiest woman on earth. I highly recommend them to anyone who is looking for an engagement ring. T hey are awesome and they deserve a 5-star review. Thank you, ring store, for making my dreams come true. You are the best!”
In 2024, Taylor M designed a pear shape salt and pepper diamond engagement ring with a braided shank in 18K yellow gold with a diamond brush finish: “So, my girlfriend proposed to me with the most gorgeous diamond in a box. She knew better than to not let me be involved in the design. We worked with Jenny at Diamonds Forever to create the most beautiful—and slightly weird—salt and pepper engagement ring, which is so me. Jenny got my vibe, and we ended up with a ring that’s unique and full of personality. The process was fun and easy, and honestly, it brought me and my fiance closer together. Now, I’m obsessed with my salt and pepper engagement ring! I can’t stop staring at it all the time. Thanks, Jenny, for making my dream ring such a good time! If you’re looking for something unique and gorgeous, Jenny’s your girl!”
In 2021, Zelda P designed a two stone engagement ring with a two pear shaped salt and pepper diamonds, one dark and peppery and the other salty light in 18K white gold: “I am absolutely beyond satisfied about my experience with Diamonds Forever! I worked with Jenny to design my engagement ring and she made the whole process so fun and exciting! I wanted something special, so we went with some fun diamonds. Jenny helped me choose the perfect stones that show both mine and my boyfriend’s personalities! The whole design process was so much fun, and Jenny really listened to all my ideas and brought them to life in the most beautiful way. I couldn’t stop smiling when I saw the final ring, it’s just perfect in every way! If you’re thinking about creating gemstone engagement rings, you’ve got to go see Jenny. She’s amazing, and the quality of her work is out of this world. I’m so happy with my ring, and I can’t recommend Diamonds Forever enough!”
In 2019, Sam M designed an engagement ring with an oval-shaped rose cut salt and pepper diamond with a broken sapphire halo in 14K white gold: “I was searching online and found Diamonds Forever. I wanted to support a small local business and that they are women-owned and run was a huge plus. This engagement ring store near me, like 5 minutes away, had everything you could want. Their selection is great and they answered every question I threw their way. They helped me get a bigger diamond than I thought I could afford and my ring is simply breathtaking.”
In 2021, Julie R designed a cushion shape rose cut salt and pepper 3-stone diamond engagement ring with a halo in 14K white gold: “I waited a long time to be able to upgrade my ring and wanted a very specific salt and pepper center stone. The ladies worked very hard to find the perfect stone and then help me design the band to go with it. Cannot recommend them enough.”
In 2019, Tina F designed a two stone engagement ring using her round heirloom diamond and pairing it with a round salt and pepper diamond in 14K rose gold: “Let me tell you, working with Jenny at Diamonds Forever was nothing short of phenomenal! I came in with my mom’s stone, something incredibly sentimental, and a dream to create an engagement ring that was as unique as I am. Jenny didn’t just meet my expectations — she blew them out of the water! From the get-go, Jenny was all ears, taking in every idea I threw at her with enthusiasm and expertise. I also found the perfect stone at Diamonds Forever, and together with my mom’s diamond, Jenny crafted an absolute modern masterpiece! The attention to detail, the creativity, and the whole process were just outstanding. I’m usually pretty particular, but Jenny nailed it! This ring is everything I wanted and more! If you want a ring that’s going to stand out and be something you’ll love forever, trust me, go see Jenny. She’s got the skills, the passion, and the eye for design that you need. I couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out, my ring is a total showstopper! Thanks, Jenny, for making this such an amazing experience!”
In 2007, Ben P designed a fantasy and antique inspired engagement ring with a very salty salt and pepper cabochon diamond in 18K yellow gold. “So, I decided to pop the big question and wanted something truly special—an antique style engagement ring that would make my fiancée swoon. Enter Diamonds Forever, the heroes of my engagement saga! From the get-go, these folks made me feel like a ring-designing wizard, guiding me through the adventurous world of antique style engagement rings with the enthusiasm of a dungeon master introducing a new campaign. Jenny, our lead designer and resident ring sorceress, was incredible. She took my somewhat nerdy, very specific ideas and turned them into an engagement ring that looks like it stepped out of a fantasy movie. The craftsmanship is out of this world, and the ring has this awesome blend of vintage charm and unique character that’s just perfect. The whole process was a blast, and I left feeling like a total hero. My fiancée adores the ring, and I couldn’t be happier. If you’re on a quest for the perfect antique style engagement ring, Diamonds Forever is where to go.”
In 2022, Michael S designed a hexagon salt and pepper diamond crown engagement ring in 18K white gold: “When I decided to propose, I knew I wanted something different that suited my fiance’s unique style. I worked with Jenny at Diamonds Forever, and after checking out several options, I discovered these incredibly cool salt and pepper diamonds. I ended up choosing a salt and pepper diamond ring with a shape that’s not only unique but looks just like a gray diamond, which was exactly the vibe I was going for. The design Jenny and I created is beautiful, and my fiance loves it! I catch her staring at it all the time, it’s perfect. The best part? I was able to get her a 3.5 carat diamond within my budget. High-five to Jenny and the entire team at Diamonds Forever. Great work, girls! If you’re looking for salt and pepper diamond engagement rings, this is the place!”
In 2019, Emily G designed a coffin shape rose cut salt and pepper diamond solitaire engagement ring with hand-engraving in 14K white gold: “OMG, where do I even start? My fiance nailed it with my salt and pepper engagement ring—beyond anything I could’ve imagined! It’s quirky, stunning, and so perfectly me! I seriously can’t stop gushing over how beautiful and unique it is. He worked with Jenny at Diamonds Forever to design the whole thing. I’m blown away by how they captured my personality in this ring. I keep staring at it like, “Is this real?! I can’t wait to meet Jenny and start designing our wedding bands together. If my salt and pepper ring is any indication, the wedding bands will be beyond fabulous. I’m so overcome with happiness and excitement! Thank you, Jenny for making this girl’s engagement dream come true!”