THE GIST: Just like your favorite little black dress, classic engagement rings are the ultimate blend of timeless elegance and effortless charm. Always ready to dazzle ~ whether you’re celebrating life’s big milestones or savoring everyday moments. They’re the go-to for those who know that classic style never fades. Ready for your classic engagement ring? Let’s create something mesmerizing together!

Classic Creations:
Forever Fabulous +
Fashion Forward

Classic engagement rings are like your favorite little black dress ~ timeless and effortlessly chic ~ and always ready to make you feel fabulous. Their sleek lines and effortless sophistication make them just as perfect for a laid-back brunch as they are for a dazzling night out. It’s no surprise that so many couples fall for these timeless designs ~ after all, true style never goes out of fashion. Ready to find your forever fabulous? Let’s create a classic ring that’s fashion-forward and uniquely you!

Tradition with
a Personal Twist

While classic rings are rooted in tradition, that doesn’t mean you can’t add a modern twist. Many of our clients love incorporating their own personal touches ~ like a hidden halo, a unique band texture, or even mixing metals. This blend of old and new creates a ring that feels uniquely yours while still holding onto the timelessness that makes it a classic. It’s like pairing your little black dress with a statement necklace ~ elegantly timeless, yet distinctly you. Ready to add your personal twist to tradition? We’re ready when you are!

The Diamonds Forever Commitment

Extraordinary Design + Extraordinary Experience: At Diamonds Forever, we’re all about making your ring dreams come true. Whether you’re swooning over the timeless beauty of a classic design ~ or itching to add your own unique touch ~ we’ve got your back every step of the way. We know this isn’t just any ring ~ it’s the ring. This is exactly why we pour our passion into every ring we craft! Ready to bring your dream ring to life? Let’s do it!

Click below to schedule
your appointment today!

Ready to find your own little black dress of engagement rings? Let us help you create something timeless, beautiful, and uniquely yours. We can’t wait to meet you!

What Our Happy Clients Say

Our clients are the magic behind every classic engagement ring we bring to life! Want to know why so many couples are smitten with these timeless beauties? Take a peek into their stories and see how we’ve turned their visions into rings that will sparkle for a lifetime. A heartfelt thank you to our wonderful clients for trusting us to craft their forever symbols of love!

In 2024, Pamela L designed a 3 mm wide solitaire engagement ring with an oval shape center diamond and a hidden halo in 14K white gold with a brushed finish:  “Working with Jenny at Diamonds Forever was an absolute dream! This was my first time designing something as important as an engagement ring. Jenny made the entire process fun and stress-free. She delivered the goods, and my girlfriend – now fiancée – is in love with her ring! The fit is a little big but pretty close, and Jenny was spot on in helping me figure that out. She told me it’s better to have it a bit big for the proposal so I could get it on her finger, then bring her back to fit it. And let me tell you, she was so right – I can’t even imagine not being able to slip it on during that moment. If you’re looking for a jeweler in San Diego who understands the importance of creating something unique and meaningful, look no further. Diamonds Forever is hands down the most LGBTQ-friendly jewelry store in town. Whether you’re after classic simple engagement rings or something totally out of the box, Jenny’s got you covered!”

In 2021, Mike R designed a modern custom engagement ring with a marquise shape center stone with hand-engraving in 14K white gold: ”If you’re looking for a top-rated engagement ring store in San Diego, Diamonds Forever should be your first stop. They were my first stop and my last stop. I shopped around at a lot other stores, but Diamonds Forever set the bar so high it was a no-brainer to go with them.”

In 2024, Molly E set her heirloom cushion shape red spinel into an antique platinum setting with tapered baguettes: “I LOVE LOVE LOVE my engagement ring! I brought in a stone that belonged to my grandmother, a pretty red ruby – or so I thought – I found out it was actually a red spinel and was floored when I found out it was rarer than a ruby. Who knew? Amy and Jenny helped me find the perfect antique ring to set it in. I’m so happy we found an actual antique to set my antque stone into. It worked out beautifully. I’m beyond happy with how it turned out! Jenny and Amy are the best, and I’m telling everyone I know to go there. If you’re looking for something special, this is the place!”

In 2023, Nick M selected an emerald cut diamond and set it into a floral-prong solitaire engagement ring in 18K yellow gold with a diamond brush finish: “I can’t thank Jenny at Diamonds Forever enough for helping me pull off a Christmas proposal! It was a real nail-biter, but Jenny came through with a beautiful ring just in time. My fiancée absolutely loves her ring, and we both couldn’t be happier. From start to finish, the entire experience was great—great quality, great service, and overall just a really pleasant experience. We’ll definitely be back to work with Jenny for our wedding rings. If you’re looking for classic oval engagement rings San Diego, especially in a time crunch, Jenny is the jeweler to see!”

In 2024, Ramona V designed a solitaire with hand engraving set with an Asscher shape lab-grown diamond in 18K white gold: “My fiancé and I were totally blown away by all the designs at Diamonds Forever, so I just had to have Jenny design a custom engagement ring for me. Seriously, I couldn’t resist! And wow, it turned out amazing. It’s simple, but the details are on point. It’s exactly what I wanted, something classic yet totally unique. If you’re looking for next-level San Diego engagement rings, Jenny’s your go-to!”

In 2022, Ethan S designed a solitaire engagement ring with an oval shape diamond center stone with bezel-set pink diamonds on the ring’s bridge in 18K white gold: “I recently had the distinct pleasure of working with Diamonds Forever in San Diego to create a diamond engagement ring solitaire with pink diamonds tastefully positioned underneath the center stone. From the outset, I was thoroughly impressed with the professionalism and expertise displayed by the entire team. Particular commendation must be given to Jenny, the lead designer, whose attention to detail and creative prowess were instrumental in bringing my vision to life. Her guidance and insightful suggestions throughout the design process were invaluable, and she ensured that every aspect of the ring was crafted to perfection. The final product exceeded all my expectations, epitomizing the quality and elegance that Diamonds Forever is known for. For anyone seeking exceptional engagement rings in San Diego, I wholeheartedly recommend Diamonds Forever. The combination of superior craftsmanship and exemplary customer service sets them apart as a must visit for San Diego engagement rings.”

In 2014, Jason A designed an engagement ring with a princess shape diamond set into an eternity prong-set diamond ring in 14K rose gold with 14K white gold prongs: “I had the pleasure of working with Jenny at Diamonds Forever to custom design a classic ring. I have to say, the ring turned out amazing! My fiancée can’t stop staring at it and she’s been referring everyone she knows. I’m just here to catch anyone she missed, seriously, this is a great jewelry store. If you’re looking for classic princess cut engagement rings that stand out, Jenny’s the one to make it happen. Couldn’t be happier!”

In 2021, Nathan P designed a solitaire engagement ring with diamond floral prongs in 14K rose gold: “Dude, I gotta give a massive shoutout to Jenny and her team at Diamonds Forever in San Diego! I was in a total pinch with only a week to pull off the perfect diamond engagement ring. I don’t know how she did it, but she totally nailed it. The ring was epic, exactly what I had in mind, and my proposal was the best ever because of it. Jenny’s got some serious skills, and her team is just as rad. They made the whole process super chill and took care of everything. If you’re wondering why a diamond ring for engagement, just check out San Diego diamonds team at Diamonds Forever – they will blow your mind. Can’t thank them enough for making it happen! I am forever in their debt. Thank you ladies!”

In 2008, Andy O designed an antique inspired engagement ring with a marquise shape yellow sapphire set into a solitaire setting in 18K yellow gold with a brushed finish: “I was on the hunt for something special and ended up with an antique-style ring with a cool shaped sapphire. It’s everything I hoped for! My buddy referred me to Diamonds Forever, and honestly, everything went perfectly. This place is the best-kept secret in San Diego, I can’t believe everyone doesn’t know about them! If you’re after classic engagement rings in San Diego that are unique, this is where you need to be. Super happy with how it all turned out!”